Page 6 of 12
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 20 Mar 2013, 21:19
by tubeguru
Just vote for 10/5 people. Put him out of his misery ...
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 20 Mar 2013, 21:46
by greatkingrat
I think it better to keep the two envelopes balanced so I'm sticking with 8/7.
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 20 Mar 2013, 22:18
by Iain
How does this work if the vote stays as it is now - more votes for change to more in the first envelope than for the status quo, but the status quo has the largest single number of votes?
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 07:49
by tubeguru
FPTP (first past the post) works by having a set number of votes that one has to reach (the "post"). This vote is surely based on a simple majority, with the possibility of a tie.
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 17:36
by nozzacook
Its going to be a big round If all 16 that have voted take part.
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 17:45
by tractakid
nozzacook wrote:Its going to be a big round If all 16 that have voted take part.
This clearly won't happen!
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 19:29
by hopeful traveller
Or we could use supplementary vote, France style!
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 20:24
by Sam
tractakid wrote:nozzacook wrote:Its going to be a big round If all 16 that have voted take part.
This clearly won't happen!
No it won't because I exercised my right to vote but have zero intention of attending

Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 20:28
by tubeguru
I keep changing my vote just to annoy Tractakid.
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 20:39
by Sam
OMG, the chaos continues...
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 20:44
by tubeguru
I haven't been following all of this closely, but this could all have been avoided by scrxisi simply TELLING everyone what the format would be instead of throwing it open to the vote.
#justsaying
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 21:34
by tubeguru
As I said, I haven't been following this closely. I have no idea how you came to decide to throw it open to a vote. I have employed the technique known as "not reading the first 7354 pages of rubbish", commenting only at the end.
I have no idea what the implications are of any of the options on offer, save that tractakid insists that one option will lead to everyone taking the same route, and the other option will not.
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 21 Mar 2013, 23:21
by tractakid
Hmmmm, you changing your vote now isn't crucial, its what it will end up on that matters. I don't believe you can withdraw. Can I trust that you will be nice?

as for winding me up, well, this vote excites me greatly, yes, but I had no clue it was you that was changing the vote so often.
I will campaign hard for my preferred option, but ultimately it will only make a small difference. Still, vote 10-5 for a more interesting challenge

Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 22 Mar 2013, 00:40
by palkanetoijala31
May i say sam that the current BERC is doing a gr8 job your future husband should do a 2nd term if he wish be nice to actually though have him turn up at one lol
Re: R15 Championship 2012/13: Round 5
Posted: 22 Mar 2013, 08:03
by Going Underground
palkanetoijala31 wrote:May i say sam that the current BERC is doing a gr8 job your future husband should do a 2nd term if he wish be nice to actually though have him turn up at one lol
hear, hear it has been a superb R15 season
