Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 09 Jun 2008, 17:42
Are you at Kilburn?
Not at Kilburn (8/20)mullardo wrote:Are you at Kilburn?
Page 2 of 3
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 10 Jun 2008, 08:05
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 12 Jun 2008, 12:02
No not on the Bakerloo line (9/20)scrxisi wrote:Are you on the Bakerloo line?
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 12 Jun 2008, 14:31
Rules Question:
A rule in a previous thread stated
"You can neither use
a) the same (or logically equivalant) nor
b) the exact opposite (or logically equivalent)
question of a single previous question asked in the same game... "
Now say you are at station A, and i pose the question "Are you not at A?"
You are not not at A. You are infact at A. However we are then not allowed to pose the question "are you at A?".
A rule in a previous thread stated
"You can neither use
a) the same (or logically equivalant) nor
b) the exact opposite (or logically equivalent)
question of a single previous question asked in the same game... "
Now say you are at station A, and i pose the question "Are you not at A?"
You are not not at A. You are infact at A. However we are then not allowed to pose the question "are you at A?".
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 12 Jun 2008, 14:35
mullardo wrote:Rules Question:
A rule in a previous thread stated
"You can neither use
a) the same (or logically equivalant) nor
b) the exact opposite (or logically equivalent)
question of a single previous question asked in the same game... "
Now say you are at station A, and i pose the question "Are you not at A?"
You are not not at A. You are infact at A. However we are then not allowed to pose the question "are you at A?".
Sorry not got a clue what you are trying to say here....
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 12 Jun 2008, 14:36
It is not possible (within this rule) to ask "are you at station A?"
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 12 Jun 2008, 14:49
I think is someone asks you if you are at a specific staion then you have to answer that question truthfully......mullardo wrote:It is not possible (within this rule) to ask "are you at station A?"
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 12 Jun 2008, 14:59
No Matt (10/20)scrxisi wrote:I understand what you are saying, but the point of phrasing such a question like that is...?
To eliminate 1 of 350+ stations? To have a guess in a weird way? It's pointless - you may as well ask "Are you at station A" - the answer given will prove just as much and won;t confuse GU
BTW, are you at Belsize Park?
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 14 Jun 2008, 09:40
Are you in zone 3-9?
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 14 Jun 2008, 12:30
Yes soupie (11/20)Soup Dragon wrote:Are you in zone 3-9?
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 14 Jun 2008, 19:08
No idea the rules are more difficult than the actual quizzes themselvesscrxisi wrote:Isn't SD's last question illegal? (though it does confirm a theory I had)
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 14 Jun 2008, 21:08
The last question wasn't illegal. A previous asked question was are you in zone 1,2. This question is Are you in zones 3-9. This question is not the logical oposite as it is only with other questions do we discover that we are in london. This is therefore not against the rules as written.
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 14 Jun 2008, 22:49
So being in London is not assumed?
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 15 Jun 2008, 13:57
Are there any stations that are in both zones 2 and 3? That would prove it not to be the logical opposite.
Re: Where am I quiz 7
Posted: 16 Jun 2008, 09:05
Not at Burnt Oak (12/20)scrxisi wrote:Are you at Burnt Oak?