"Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Got anything to say that's not about the Tube? Say it here!
Post Reply
User avatar
Tube Geek
The Twilight Zone
Posts: 3601
Joined: 31 Mar 2016, 19:06
Location: BS20 or BS3
Contact:

"Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by Tube Geek » 06 Dec 2016, 08:00

As mentioned here, the prospect of a TCA Association isn't ridiculous.... I'd be happy to do it from home!
Personal Best - 264 Stations in 19 hours 37 minutes.

Bristol City fan through and through - COME ON YOU REDS

User avatar
Steeevooo
All Zones
Posts: 1061
Joined: 14 Jul 2005, 11:23
Location: Chadwell Heath

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by Steeevooo » 06 Dec 2016, 10:53

Or we could just let Guinness World Records continue to do what they have been doing (albeit with varying degrees of ineptitude) for many years in adjudicating world record attempts in accordance with the criteria that they lay down.

Why would anyone trust a 12 year old with absolutely zero tube challenge experience to cast an eye over and adjudicate a record? The fact that you have to put "Official" does kind of show that there would be absolutely nothing official about it too.

User avatar
Tube Geek
The Twilight Zone
Posts: 3601
Joined: 31 Mar 2016, 19:06
Location: BS20 or BS3
Contact:

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by Tube Geek » 06 Dec 2016, 13:19

Not official record, but if (say) it was turned down by GWR, someone could check.it before putting it on here..
Personal Best - 264 Stations in 19 hours 37 minutes.

Bristol City fan through and through - COME ON YOU REDS

User avatar
tubeguru
Site Administrator
Posts: 8841
Joined: 30 Jan 2005, 22:08
Location: The Twilight Zone
Contact:

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by tubeguru » 06 Dec 2016, 16:22

Guinness, one assumes, have a means of contacting LUL to check train times and numbers. That hasn't changed over the years has it? I always thought that Guinness would be able to contact someone in the know at LUL, who would be able to confirm that the claimed journeys had been made.

I'm wondering how Tube Geek plans on getting that information to verify an attempt. And if GWR *did* turn a record attempt down I'm sure they'd have a good reason, not one that could simply be overturned by a member of the public trying to find out why. I know certain people on this forum (including certain ex-members) have criticised Guinness for refusing to recognise some attempts they have made, but I'm sure there must have been a good reason for it.

We're not really able to claim to be better-placed than Guinness to verify attempts, so the whole thing is nonsense.
One thing only do I know, and that is that I know nothing - Socrates.

Champion of bugger all, 2004 to 2018
Member of sweet FA

User avatar
greatkingrat
All Zones
Posts: 2412
Joined: 11 Feb 2005, 00:35

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by greatkingrat » 06 Dec 2016, 16:57

You have greater faith in Guinness than I do. I don't think they check the log at all. Remember it takes them several months to verify the record by which time the data might not be available anyway and I suspect LU staff have better things to do than go back and check whether train 123 to Mill Hill East did indeed depart at 10:46:32 on the 15th June.

I think anyone on this forum could come up with evidence that looks plausible enough to claim a fake record if they really wanted to.
Soon to be yet another forum train driver

GuyBarry
The Twilight Zone
Posts: 5334
Joined: 01 Aug 2011, 08:24

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by GuyBarry » 06 Dec 2016, 17:00

tubeguru wrote:Guinness, one assumes, have a means of contacting LUL to check train times and numbers. That hasn't changed over the years has it? I always thought that Guinness would be able to contact someone in the know at LUL, who would be able to confirm that the claimed journeys had been made.
They could confirm that those trains had run, but not that those journeys had been made. As far as I know LUL do not keep records of every passenger getting on and off every train.
Undefeated Tumbleweed champion, Oct 2015

Inventor of Grumbleweed, Nimbleweed, Timesnap, Postsnap and several other silly games

User avatar
tubeguru
Site Administrator
Posts: 8841
Joined: 30 Jan 2005, 22:08
Location: The Twilight Zone
Contact:

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by tubeguru » 06 Dec 2016, 17:20

greatkingrat wrote:You have greater faith in Guinness than I do. I don't think they check the log at all. Remember it takes them several months to verify the record by which time the data might not be available anyway and I suspect LU staff have better things to do than go back and check whether train 123 to Mill Hill East did indeed depart at 10:46:32 on the 15th June.

I think anyone on this forum could come up with evidence that looks plausible enough to claim a fake record if they really wanted to.
It would be nice if we could actually KNOW what Guinness do when presented with a record attempt.
One thing only do I know, and that is that I know nothing - Socrates.

Champion of bugger all, 2004 to 2018
Member of sweet FA

A Challenge
The Twilight Zone
Posts: 3932
Joined: 24 Jan 2015, 07:57
Location: London Waterloo

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by A Challenge » 07 Dec 2016, 06:34

tubeguru wrote:
greatkingrat wrote:You have greater faith in Guinness than I do. I don't think they check the log at all. Remember it takes them several months to verify the record by which time the data might not be available anyway and I suspect LU staff have better things to do than go back and check whether train 123 to Mill Hill East did indeed depart at 10:46:32 on the 15th June.

I think anyone on this forum could come up with evidence that looks plausible enough to claim a fake record if they really wanted to.
It would be nice if we could actually KNOW what Guinness do when presented with a record attempt.
Tonight: Inside Guinness World Record
Inside Guinness World Records: Panorama

Don't think there is a chance that either of these would ever happen though!
Tumbleweed and former Nimbleweed Scorekeeper

Winner of Gumbleweeds V, VI + XI, Nimbleweeds I, III - IX + XIV and (joint with GuyBarry) winner of Timesnap

And most importantly, Former leader of Tumbleweed, and first person to 250,000

User avatar
Tube Geek
The Twilight Zone
Posts: 3601
Joined: 31 Mar 2016, 19:06
Location: BS20 or BS3
Contact:

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by Tube Geek » 07 Dec 2016, 06:51

Unless there was some kind of major scandal involving them...
Personal Best - 264 Stations in 19 hours 37 minutes.

Bristol City fan through and through - COME ON YOU REDS

Nigel
Zone 5
Posts: 623
Joined: 06 Jan 2008, 19:04
Location: Woodford

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by Nigel » 07 Dec 2016, 08:28

tubeguru wrote: It would be nice if we could actually KNOW what Guinness do when presented with a record attempt.
As some members of the forum know, a few years ago, I entered into a dialogue with Guinness about some doubts that existed about a recently ratified record. These doubts were fuelled by misinformation that had been put out by the record holder about their route, which had led some to suppose that apparent inconsistencies were evidence of malpractice.

After an initial exchange of letters with Guinness about the issue, I then spoke on a couple of occasions with the adjudicator of this claim. She was based in New York, and while she tried to be diligent in checking the evidence presented, she had no real knowledge of the London Underground system and had not verified anything with TfL.

User avatar
Going Underground
The Twilight Zone
Posts: 8043
Joined: 11 Apr 2006, 11:24
Location: Down in a tube station at midnight.
Contact:

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by Going Underground » 07 Dec 2016, 12:25

I have mentioned before you could quite easily get a GWR for this sat cosily at home....
Twice former full network GWR holder and former Zone 1 Olympic and World Record holder with The Raven and Soupie
Tube personality of the year 2009
Twice Winter Olympic Biathlon Gold Medalist with The Beer Baron
2008 All Lines Olympic Gold

nozzacook
All Zones
Posts: 1157
Joined: 17 Apr 2006, 15:45
Location: Zone 900

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by nozzacook » 27 Jan 2017, 08:07

Going Underground wrote:I have mentioned before you could quite easily get a GWR for this sat cosily at home....
This is why Guinness are trying too get applicants to send oyster records as well.
26 miles 385yards in 4h 14m 40s.

User avatar
moley
Site Administrator
Posts: 1907
Joined: 07 May 2005, 12:38
Location: Portsmouth
Contact:

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by moley » 28 Jan 2017, 17:47

Nigel wrote:
tubeguru wrote: It would be nice if we could actually KNOW what Guinness do when presented with a record attempt.
As some members of the forum know, a few years ago, I entered into a dialogue with Guinness about some doubts that existed about a recently ratified record. These doubts were fuelled by misinformation that had been put out by the record holder about their route, which had led some to suppose that apparent inconsistencies were evidence of malpractice.

After an initial exchange of letters with Guinness about the issue, I then spoke on a couple of occasions with the adjudicator of this claim. She was based in New York, and while she tried to be diligent in checking the evidence presented, she had no real knowledge of the London Underground system and had not verified anything with TfL.
The last time we claimed a record were sent a list of queries based on our rather full portfolio of evidence. This led me to believe that Guinness use information in the public domain to verify claims. That said, more information than ever is in the public domain.

You have to remember that there are three levels of verification:
Very premium: on the day Guinness attendance at attempt to verify then and there,
Premium: quick turnaround.
Everyone else.

As I understand it, the Guinness headcount is relatively small and that number of people is spread across the globe. Therefore the more very premium / premium requests, the longer everyone else's claim takes. Likewise, when they are preparing the book, it seems to take longer.
Tube Forum administrator. I look after the database to keep this place running smoothly.

RJSRdg
Zone 6
Posts: 707
Joined: 16 Mar 2015, 00:35

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by RJSRdg » 27 Aug 2017, 23:10

GuyBarry wrote:
06 Dec 2016, 17:00
tubeguru wrote:Guinness, one assumes, have a means of contacting LUL to check train times and numbers. That hasn't changed over the years has it? I always thought that Guinness would be able to contact someone in the know at LUL, who would be able to confirm that the claimed journeys had been made.
They could confirm that those trains had run, but not that those journeys had been made. As far as I know LUL do not keep records of every passenger getting on and off every train.
They do (CCTV footage) but only for 20 days.
Currently 4th place in the Bottle Challenge league table
Currently 3rd place Zone1/Zone 2 Challenge

FelixJ20000
Zone 2
Posts: 68
Joined: 19 Oct 2014, 16:21

Re: "Official" Tube Challenge Adjudicators

Post by FelixJ20000 » 25 Sep 2017, 07:04

Would it be so ridiculous to form a small governing body? *shrugs*

(not saying it should be in the hands of a 12 year old - no offence to you Tube Geek)

Post Reply